[lug] Forcing a Sound Device

Sun Nov 12 12:04:56 MST 2017

Just an additional note: I went into the BIOS and disabled the integrated audio. While doing that I saw that it has settings of enabled, disabled, and auto. It was on enabled, so it seems this makes the system think the speakers are always plugged in. Even so, software shouldn't force this as a fallback device every time a song ends.

After disabling this also shows only my video card audio devices and USB headset, which is what I want. Unfortunately, audio is broken because firefox and even the pulse audio mixer application lose all devices...even the ones "aplay -l" shows are gone from playback. The pavucontrol just says its broken and has no devices. It looks like pulse must be a PCM layer on top of alsa...wish I knew. If this is the case, then it is probably pulse audio which is causing a device revert and buggy behavior.

----- Original Message -----From: stimits at comcast.netTo: Boulder (Colorado) Linux Users Group -- General Mailing List <lug at lug.boulder.co.us>Sent: Sun, 12 Nov 2017 18:46:56 -0000 (UTC)Subject: Re: [lug] Forcing a Sound Device

Thanks for the reply! Unfortunately I think your control has more in it than this one. I can set a device to muted, but not to disabled by this method. When I set the USB headphones as default, any removal of them results in a permanent switch to analog motherboard output and never goes back to headphones when the headphones are reconnected. It probably does not matter because no device is getting audio now unless I use a pulse audio control.

If I run the "pavucontrol" application, this too has a default device list, but no matter which device I select, each song forces it back to built in analog audio...the device setting works for one song, then reverts. Wish I knew what file pavucontrol alters...I'd use SElinux and make it immutable to everything. Or if I knew what it is that tells pavucontrol to change, I'd bzip2 the binary so it can't be used (at this point I don't care if it brings down the system...I just want to know debugging information).

In the pavucontrol output device tab I have no ability to remove built-in analog audio, all I can do is uncheck it as a fallback device. HDMI never has output unless I turn the monitor off and back on and then use pavucontrol to set the individual firefox playback device to HDMI...and after the song is done firefox reverts to analog integrated audio.

Anyone know why pulse audio is used? I'm not sure if I could remove it and have things work...it seems using purely alsa would be best.

----- Original Message -----From: Alan Robertson <alanr at unix.sh>To: lug at lug.boulder.co.usSent: Sun, 12 Nov 2017 15:12:20 -0000 (UTC)Subject: Re: [lug] Forcing a Sound Device

I use KDE on Ubuntu (Kubuntu) and always use a non-default audio device. Here's how I make that happen on Kubuntu:

right click the speaker icon, and bring up Audio Volume Settings.

Click on the configuration tab (far right tab).

For all your unwanted audio devices, click on Profile and select "off".

Click OK.

It works for Kubuntu - don't know about Fedora.

--
  Alan Robertson
  alanr at unix.sh

On Sat, Nov 11, 2017, at 03:51 PM, stimits at comcast.net wrote:

I've tried a number of things to get a change in the default audio on my Fedora/KDE system. For whatever reason, no matter what I do, every playback device wants to start with the built in analog audio of the motherboard. I can change this to use the HDMI or USB audio...as soon as a song or video ends, it reverts. If I watch a video and go to full screen...it reverts. I don't have the analog audio on the motherboard connected.

Various mixers have allowed me to change default audio device. Until the song or video ends...then it reverts to being default.

One of the things I tried was to blacklist the motherboard's kernel module for the device...but apparently other things depend on this despite no other module depending on this. I can remove the module, and no other module reports needing it, but no mixer or audio application works after that. The USB headset has its own digital audio, and the video card for HDMI has its audio...I do not believe the integrated audio should have any effect unless other programs mistakenly demand to open integrated audio.

I've also tried settings in pulse audio's default.pa, but these seem to fail as well.

Does anyone have any idea how I can summarily ban the motherboard's integrated audio? I'm about to try disabling it in the BIOS, but this is a multi-boot system and I suspect this will cause other issues which I won't be able to set right again once it happens (short of a full system restore). I'd love to find a file I can remove write permission to and set SElinux permissions to deny write to anyone or anything...ever...but I don't know where this default setting is coming from if the mixer GUI's set a value and then it reverts. I cannot find the file. I suspect it is in udev.

There are too many mechanisms for audio...pulse, alsa, KDE, gnome, systemd, udev. I really wish there were just one mechanism and it worked.

Thanks!
_______________________________________________
Web Page:  http://lug.boulder.co.us
Mailing List: http://lists.lug.boulder.co.us/mailman/listinfo/lug
Join us on IRC: irc.hackingsociety.org port=6667 channel=#hackingsociety

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.lug.boulder.co.us/pipermail/lug/attachments/20171112/d6259d32/attachment.html>